|
Post by Emi-chan on Apr 19, 2005 15:48:11 GMT -5
Though I see no real basis for that. And he does seem to "mature" some throughout teh series, so that would seem to go against that line of reasoning. I have plenty of basis for this... but a hard time putting it to words. Most of its From Fushigi Yugi... and Chiriko's two personalities... and something Nuriko said in Oni... and a bunch of other similar things. teh thing Nuriko said was "Hey, you're older than me now." And I'd say that he and Al are in a similar boat, their spirit is still alive... but not their bodies... and teh whole basis of reincarnation.
|
|
|
Post by XerBlade on Apr 19, 2005 18:01:37 GMT -5
I have plenty of basis for this... but a hard time putting it to words. Most of its From Fushigi Yugi... and Chiriko's two personalities... and something Nuriko said in Oni... and a bunch of other similar things. teh thing Nuriko said was "Hey, you're older than me now." And I'd say that he and Al are in a similar boat, their spirit is still alive... but not their bodies... and teh whole basis of reincarnation. Another part of teh basis of reincarnation is teh erasure of memories of teh previous life.
|
|
|
Post by Emi-chan on Apr 19, 2005 21:38:51 GMT -5
Another part of teh basis of reincarnation is teh erasure of memories of teh previous life. True enough, and yet what has happened to Al? His memories of before he was attached to teh armor is where exactly? Also... pointing to FY as a refrence... teh seishi remembered their past lives in their reincarnated lives in Eikoden, and as much as I hate it... it works. Also I still hafta point out hte two extreems that is Chiriko... he is thirteen years old... but half teh time he is much older mentaly, and teh other half he is much younger.
|
|
|
Post by XerBlade on Apr 19, 2005 22:42:23 GMT -5
True enough, and yet what has happened to Al? His memories of before he was attached to teh armor is where exactly? Also... pointing to FY as a refrence... teh seishi remembered their past lives in their reincarnated lives in Eikoden, and as much as I hate it... it works. Also I still hafta point out hte two extreems that is Chiriko... he is thirteen years old... but half teh time he is much older mentaly, and teh other half he is much younger. What exactly do you mean? He still has his memories from before he was attached to teh armor just fine, though he has forgotten a few little ones here and there due to teh natural passage of time and all. You know, how you keep getting new memories and some of teh less important old ones get pushed back and all.
|
|
|
Post by Emi-chan on Apr 19, 2005 22:58:51 GMT -5
What exactly do you mean? He still has his memories from before he was attached to teh armor just fine, though he has forgotten a few little ones here and there due to teh natural passage of time and all. You know, how you keep getting new memories and some of teh less important old ones get pushed back and all. ... *throws a sock-ball at you* You make no sense! THats not exactly whats going on with Al... And I can't think of how to put into words what I'm thinking. Danged ideas that come in pictures and not words... Oh... and if Al gets his body back, wouldn't it be exactly teh same age he was when he lost it, thus he wouldn't have aged any.
|
|
|
Post by Hina-chan on Apr 20, 2005 0:16:44 GMT -5
... *throws a sock-ball at you* You make no sense! THats not exactly whats going on with Al... And I can't think of how to put into words what I'm thinking. Danged ideas that come in pictures and not words... Oh... and if Al gets his body back, wouldn't it be exactly teh same age he was when he lost it, thus he wouldn't have aged any. Sorry Xer, but I feel like Emi does...kinda I think...o.0
Al remembers nits an peices but there is too much missing.....mostly because like it or not, Ed did MAKE Al's soul. Yes it is Al's soul, but as it is with all alchemy you hafta know what your making to make it so whatever Ed put into Al's soul is there.
And Emi, I'm not even gonna talk about that last bit >____< :: scoots away to watch teh new movie trailer ::
|
|
|
Post by XerBlade on Apr 20, 2005 0:39:57 GMT -5
... *throws a sock-ball at you* You make no sense! THats not exactly whats going on with Al... And I can't think of how to put into words what I'm thinking. Danged ideas that come in pictures and not words... Oh... and if Al gets his body back, wouldn't it be exactly teh same age he was when he lost it, thus he wouldn't have aged any. There... is some complicated stuff behind all of that....
|
|
|
Post by XerBlade on Apr 20, 2005 0:43:29 GMT -5
Sorry Xer, but I feel like Emi does...kinda I think...o.0
Al remembers nits an peices but there is too much missing.....mostly because like it or not, Ed did MAKE Al's soul. Yes it is Al's soul, but as it is with all alchemy you hafta know what your making to make it so whatever Ed put into Al's soul is there.
And Emi, I'm not even gonna talk about that last bit >____< :: scoots away to watch teh new movie trailer :: How much of teh does teh average 14 year old remember of when he was like 5 anyway? He'll tend to remember very little of it, not even counting teh psychological stuff going along with all teh stuff he's been through in teh past several years. Anyway, technically he didn't make Al's soul. He used that blood seal and sacrificed his arm to call his soul back from within teh... thing I'm not supposed to spoil... while leaving his physical body there, which he wasn't able to call back at teh time.
|
|
|
Post by snapdragon76 on Apr 20, 2005 9:01:37 GMT -5
:: scoots away to watch teh new movie trailer ::Oooh, you must tell me about teh trailer...
|
|
|
Post by Emi-chan on Apr 20, 2005 10:15:47 GMT -5
Sorry Xer, but I feel like Emi does...kinda I think...o.0
Al remembers nits an peices but there is too much missing.....mostly because like it or not, Ed did MAKE Al's soul. Yes it is Al's soul, but as it is with all alchemy you hafta know what your making to make it so whatever Ed put into Al's soul is there.
And Emi, I'm not even gonna talk about that last bit >____< :: scoots away to watch teh new movie trailer :: YAY! See, Xer is out voted. *why this is significant I don't know... but Xer loses. Anywho... I'm just using what little knowledge I currently hafta come up with this theory, and if I'm sometime/somehow proven wrong, I'll probably be teh first one to admit it. THat last bit was taken from teh fact that every time Ed thinks of Al he always sees teh "younger" because thats how he remembers Al, and thats how Al actually is. Also I think that what memories Al has are actually all of, or most of, are Ed's memories since Ed did hafta "create" al's soul and all that jazz. Ed wouldn't know ALL of Al's memories and could only "make" ones he already knew about.
|
|
|
Post by Emi-chan on Apr 20, 2005 10:17:06 GMT -5
Oooh, you must tell me about teh trailer... Ooh... I agree with Snap! Spill girlie!
|
|
|
Post by XerBlade on Apr 20, 2005 12:51:54 GMT -5
YAY! See, Xer is out voted. *why this is significant I don't know... but Xer loses. Anywho... I'm just using what little knowledge I currently hafta come up with this theory, and if I'm sometime/somehow proven wrong, I'll probably be teh first one to admit it. THat last bit was taken from teh fact that every time Ed thinks of Al he always sees teh "younger" because thats how he remembers Al, and thats how Al actually is. Also I think that what memories Al has are actually all of, or most of, are Ed's memories since Ed did hafta "create" al's soul and all that jazz. Ed wouldn't know ALL of Al's memories and could only "make" ones he already knew about. Except teh things he doesn't remember are things Ed did know.... And besides, they very clearly stated in teh show, though technically not yet anyway... that Ed did not "create" Al's soul that is stuck to teh armor.
|
|
|
Post by XerBlade on Apr 20, 2005 12:52:45 GMT -5
Ooh... I agree with Snap! Spill girlie! Anything said so much about a trailer would be spoiling massive stuff from teh show. teh movie is based after teh show ends, by teh way.
|
|
|
Post by snapdragon76 on Apr 20, 2005 12:59:41 GMT -5
Anything said so much about a trailer would be spoiling massive stuff from teh show. teh movie is based after teh show ends, by teh way. I don't care... Spill away!
|
|
|
Post by Hina-chan on Apr 20, 2005 17:02:38 GMT -5
I don't care... Spill away! .......Anything I say ruins teh end...T.T I dunno how MUCH you want spoiled.....um...if it helps teh movie looks kinda cool.....There's some bits I think they should've done differently from what I've seen, but I'll hafta wait till I *SEE* teh movie to decide for certain if I really don't like teh way they did...what...they did.....that doesn't really make sense does it?
ah....well I'll be on teh net until 9:30 tonight so I'll check back here...let me know how much you two want spoiled and I'll tell you all about it. ^___^ I don't mind giving spoilers, but only when people are certain they want them. Or if I don't like a person I'll 'accidently' spoil stuff....oops
|
|